Offender Exclusive: Dissecting The Kit Martin Case with Emilio Corsetti
As the tape rolls for the second episode of the riveting Offender True Crime Podcast series, "Flying into the Danger Zone: The Kit Martin Case," we're greeted by the familiar voices of our tenacious hosts, Mic Marlowe and Crystal McKenzie. This time, they're sharing the studio with acclaimed true crime author Emilio Corsetti, who's hard at work on his forthcoming book, "I Will Ruin You," centered around the complex Kit Martin case.
This episode feels like a descent down a rabbit hole, revealing one twist after another in the tragic saga of injustice that has haunted Kit Martin. Corsetti, using his expertise in true crime storytelling, paints a vivid picture of the prosecution's shaky theory, exposing the alleged missteps of Assistant AG Barbara Whaley and Lt. Scott Smith. Oh, and let's make some Noisworthy. Christian Co. Sherriff Deputy Scott Noisworthy has some explaining to do about various calls he received while investigating this case.
Together, our hosts and their guest untangle the controversy surrounding the decision to weaponize Martin's military experience in court. They comb through the layers of misrepresented evidence presented to the unsuspecting jury, prompting us to question the integrity of the entire process.
A particularly chilling moment comes when they delve into the mystery of Pam's phone. How did it ping off a cell tower in Elkton, Kentucky, where Joan Harmon lived, only to be discovered weeks later in a front yard? This puzzling fact has ignited a social media frenzy, with #JoanHadThePhone trending as listeners worldwide grapple with this eerie detail.
The episode doesn't stop at unraveling the mystery of the phone. Our hosts urge listeners to look into the alleged corruption at KSP Madisonville post 2 in KY, where Lt. Leonard Scott Smith served before his retirement and subsequent involvement with the Kit Martin case. Smith's intricate testimony and sudden ascent to the lead investigator of the Christian County police department post-retirement only add to the murky intrigue surrounding this case.
Perhaps the most baffling segment of the episode involves Joan Harmon and her suspicious handling of Pam Phillips' phone, which appeared in an AT&T store six weeks after the murders. The question isn't just why, but how? Jonathon Reeves' testimony suggests that while Kit Martin's phone headed south to
Fort Campbell, Pam's somehow ended up in Elkton, KY. Emilio Corsetti highlights the pressing need for a clear, straightforward visual aid that could have emphasized the significance of this piece of evidence to the jurors.
As the episode comes to a close, the conversation circles back to Emilio's upcoming book. There's an electric anticipation in the air, and we can almost see the glow of the studio lights reflecting off the unwritten pages of "I Will Ruin You." Amid the accolades for Emilio's commitment to uncovering the truth, there's an undertone of resolve. The fight for justice isn't over, and as the hosts sign off, we're left eagerly awaiting the next installment in this profound exploration of the Kit Martin case.
Thanks for listening, Offender True Crime Nation! Be sure to follow us on Twitter, Facebook, Instagram, and TikTok to learn more about upcoming episodes. As always, stay curious, stay vigilant, and never stop asking questions. offendertruecrime.com
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free