When investigators in Alachua County, Florida discovered the remains of two people among the charred ruins of a burned down shack and a letter in a nearby car that seemed to explain the entire scene, police in two states thought they were on the brink of closing a multiple murder case that started all the way north in New Hampshire. But as experts attempted to identify the two people found in that shack, doubt started to poke glaring holes in the case.
If you haven’t already, go back one episode and listen to Part 1 of this series. You’ll want to hear where this case all began in Jackson, New Hampshire.
View source material and photos for this episode at: darkdowneast.com/malcolmelizabethandpagejenningspart2
Dark Downeast is an audiochuck and Kylie Media production hosted by Kylie Low.
The Murder of Helen Jewett (New York)
The Still Unsolved Murder of Darien Richardson (Maine)
The Murders of Jack & Florence Bettencourt (Maine)
The Suspicious Death of Morgan Patten Part 2 (North Carolina)
The Suspicious Death of Morgan Patten Part 1 (North Carolina)
The Murders of Sandra Valade, Pamela Mason & Rena Paquette (New Hampshire)
The Murders of Carrie Moss & Sonya Moore (New Hampshire)
The Murder of Susan Taraskiewicz (Massachusetts)
The Haunted Lighthouses of Seguin & Boon Island (Maine)
The Murder of Judith Flagg (Maine)
The Disappearances of Tina & Bethany Sinclair (New Hampshire)
The Murder of Tammy Dickson (Maine)
The Disappearance of Robert "Bobby" Desmond (Maine)
UPDATED: The Murder of Leslie Spellman (Maine)
A Conversation with Ashley Flowers, Host of Crime Junkie
The Cons of Mair Smith Part 2 (Maine)
The Cons of Mair Smith Part 1 (Maine)
The Murders of Dominic Kirmil and Irvin Hilton (Massachusetts)
The Murder of Kenneth Zernicke (Maine)
The Death of Elmer McCurdy (Maine)
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Ghosts of Dallas
Park Predators
Crime Junkie
The Vanished Podcast
20/20
48 Hours