The Nonlinear Library: EA Forum
Education
Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: Pre-slaughter mortality of farmed shrimp, published by Hannah McKay on March 12, 2024 on The Effective Altruism Forum.Citation: McKay, H. and McAuliffe, W. (2024). Pre-slaughter mortality of farmed shrimp. Rethink Priorities.https://doi.org/10.17605/OSF.IO/W7MUZThe report is also available as apdf here.Executive summaryMortality rates are high in shrimp aquaculture, implying welfare threats are common.It is typical for ~50% of shrimp to die before reaching slaughter age.This equates to around 1.2 billion premature deaths a day on average.Mortality varies among species; prioritizing interventions should take this into account.Because of high pre-slaughter mortality (~81%), Macrobrachium shrimp represent a larger share of farmed shrimp than slaughtered shrimp.Most individual deaths are P. vannamei, despite having the lowest mortality rate.More larvae die than any other life stage, but this does not necessarily mean efforts should focus on them.Uncertainty remains about whether larval shrimp are sentient - they are planktonic, so do not make autonomous decisions.Minimizing larval deaths could cause compensatory deaths in later life stages (e.g., ensuring weaker larvae survive, who then die from later harsh conditions).Interventions should likely concentrate on the ongrowing stage (postlarval and juvenile-subadult shrimp), where there are still tens of billions of deaths.There are several causes of mortality and differences between farm types.Most causes are likely a combination of intrinsic shrimp traits (e.g., young shrimp are sensitive to environmental fluctuations), farming practices, and diseases.Disease is a main cause throughout life, but it is often a downstream effect of issues that farmers have some control over (e.g., poor water quality).Variation among reported figures, especially that more intensive farms have fewer deaths, suggests many factors are at play and that some are controllable.The effects of reducing early mortality on industry trajectory are uncertain.The number of shrimp born may decrease if farmers must produce fixed output. But shrimp would live longer, increasing the chances for negative experiences.However, consumer demand has historically outstripped supply, so the industry may grow if it had better control of conditions causing mortality.If reduced deaths come from intensification of practices, more shrimp may be reared in conditions that can harm welfare (e.g., high stocking densities).Pre-slaughter mortality cannot depict total welfare because it misses nonfatal effects.Mortality is only a lower-bound proxy of how many shrimp suffer negative welfare.Premature mortality is more appropriate as one indicator among many that a welfare reform was successful, rather than an end in itself.Pre-slaughter mortality data is limited and non-uniform.Reports should clarify whether mass die-off events were excluded from mortality estimates and if rates are based on intuition from experience or empirical studies.Box 1: Shrimp aquaculture terminologyThe terms 'shrimp' and 'prawn' are often used interchangeably. The two terms do not reliably track any phylogenetic differences between species. Here, we use only the term "shrimp", covering both shrimp and prawns. Note that members of the family Artemiidae are commonly referred to as "brine shrimp" but are not decapods and so are beyond the present scope.We opt for the use of Penaues vannamei over Litopenaeus vannamei (to which this species is often referred), due to recognition of the former but not the latter nomenclature by ITIS, WorMS, and the Food and Agriculture Organization of the United Nations (FAO) ASFIS List of Species for Fishery Statistics Purposes.The shrimp farming industry uses many terms usually associated with agriculture - for example, 'crops' for a group o...
EA - Some more marginal Long-Term Future Fund grants by calebp
EA - Rethink Priorities' 2023 Summary, 2024 Strategy, and Funding Gaps by kierangreig
EA - HearMeOut - Networking While Funding Charities (Looking for a founder and beta users) by Brad West
EA - Notes on not taking the GWWC pledge (yet) by Lizka
EA - Maternal Health Initiative - Marginal Funding & 1st Year in Review by Ben Williamson
EA - How would your project use extra funding? (Marginal Funding Week) by Lizka
EA - Funding AI Safety political advocacy in the US: Individual donors and small donations may be especially helpful by Holly Elmore
EA - Pitfalls to consider when community-building with young people by frances lorenz
EA - Donation Election: how voting will work by Lizka
EA - Survey on the acceleration risks of our new RFPs to study LLM capabilities by Ajeya
EA - Getting Started with Impact Evaluation Surveys: A Beginner's Guide by Emily Grundy
EA - The effective altruist case for pro-life/anti-abortion advocacy by Calum Miller
EA - AMA: The Humane League UK - farmed animal welfare, our funding gap and match funding campaign. Ask us anything. by Gavin Chappell-Bates
EA - Kids or No Kids by KidsOrNoKids
EA - Webinar invitation: learn how to use Rethink Priorities' new prioritization tool by Rethink Priorities
EA - How we work, #2: We look at specific opportunities, not just general interventions by GiveWell
EA - A robust earning to give ecosystem is better for EA by abrahamrowe
EA - Who is Sam Bankman-Fried (SBF) really, and how could he have done what he did? - three theories and a lot of evidence by spencerg
EA - Memo on some neglected topics by Lukas Finnveden
EA - Further possible projects on EA reform by Julia Wise
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Positive Thinking Mind
In the Great Khan’s Tent
Visualize Meditations
The Mel Robbins Podcast
The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast