The Nonlinear Library: EA Forum
Education
Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: There and back again: reflections from leaving EA (and returning), published by LotteG on March 18, 2024 on The Effective Altruism Forum.This is aDraft Amnesty Week draft. It may not be polished, up to my usual standards, fully thought through, or fully fact-checked.Commenting and feedback guidelines:This is a Forum post that I wouldn't have posted without the nudge of Draft Amnesty Week, and is indeed my first ever forum post. Fire away! (But be nice, as usual)In Autumn 2016, as a first year undergraduate, I discovered Effective Altruism. Although I don't remember my inaugural meeting with EA, it must have had a big impact on me, because in a few short months I was all in. At the time, I was a physics student who had grown up with a deep - but not yet concrete - motivation to "make the world a better place".I had not yet formed any solid career ambitions, as I was barely aware of the kinds of careers that even existed for mathsy people like me - let alone any that would make me feel morally fulfilled. When I encountered EA, it felt like everything was finally slotting together. My nineteen year old brain was buzzing with the possibilities ahead.But by the following summer, barely a single fraying thread held me to EA. I had severed myself from EA and its community.Several years on, I have somehow found myself even more involved in EA than I was before (and, once again, I'm not fully sure how this happened). Now, I work in an EA job, engage with EA content, and even have EA friends (!). I genuinely believe that if I had not left EA when I did, then I wouldn't be able to describe my current relationship with EA in the two ways I do now: sustainable and healthy.Reflecting back on this transition, I have three key takeaways, specifically aimed at EA-aligned grads who are making their entry into the workforce.Disclaimers:These reflections probably do not apply in all cases. Most likely, there is variation in applicability by cause area, type of work, person, organisation, etc. This post is from my own perspective. For context, I work in operations.None of my commentary below is intended as a criticism of any specific org or institution. I simply hope to open people's minds to paths which go against what is seen as the default route to impact for many EAs coming out of university.(1) Skill building >> impressiveness factorMy reservations with elite private institutionsI often hear career advice in the EA space along the lines of:"Aim for the most impressive thing that you can get on your CV as quickly as possible, and by impressive we mean something like working somewhere elite in the private sector."I disagree with this advice on two levels:1. Effort pay-off??Emphasising the impressiveness-factor of a career move shifts focus away from what actually should be the priority: the skills gained.During my time away from EA, I saw many of my non-EA peers seek extremely prestigious roles at elite institutions - think Google, Goldman Sachs, PwC, and so on. Something that really struck me was how competitive, high-effort, time-consuming, and stressful the hiring rounds for these jobs were.And if they were lucky enough to beat the huge amounts of competition and get the job, yeah it would look great on their LinkedIn - but the tradeoff was often working long hours in a pressure-cooker environment, in a role that sometimes involved a high proportion of donkey work.The bias towards prestigious-sounding jobs is widespread across society, so it is no surprise that this has also proliferated EA. Among EAs, I suppose, the allure of such jobs is based on the assumption that the more prestigious an establishment, the better they will train you due to having greater resources.But think about it this way: given how much time, effort and (as you are probabilistically l...
EA - Summer Internships at Open Philanthropy - Global Catastrophic Risks (due March 4) by Hazel Browne
EA - CLR Summer Research Fellowship 2024 by Center on Long-Term Risk
EA - Coworking space in Mexico City by AmAristizabal
EA - Estimates on expected effects of movement/pressure group/field building? by jackva
EA - Social science research we'd like to see on global health and wellbeing [Open Philanthropy] by Aaron Gertler
EA - Works in Progress: The Long Journey to Doing Good Better by Dustin Moskovitz [Linkpost] by Nathan Young
EA - 80,000 Hours' new series on building skills by Benjamin Hilton
EA - FTX expects to return all customer money; clawbacks may go away by MikhailSamin
EA - Complexity of value but not disvalue implies more focus on s-risk. Moral uncertainty and preference utilitarianism also do. by Chi
EA - Announcing leadership changes at One for the World by Emma Cameron
EA - My lifelong pledge to give away 10% of my income each year (and where I donated in 2023) by James Ãzden
EA - My cover story in Jacobin on AI capitalism and the x-risk debates by Garrison
EA - On being an EA for decades by Michelle Hutchinson
EA - Things to check about a job or internship by Julia Wise
EA - Tragic Beliefs by tobytrem
EA - Ambitious Impact (AIM) - a new brand for Charity Entrepreneurship and our extended ecosystem! by CE
EA - Celebrating Benjamin Lay (died on this day 265 years ago) by Lizka
EA - Upcoming changes to the EV US and EV UK leadership teams by Rob Gledhill
EA - LawAI's Summer Research Fellowship - apply by February 16 by LawAI
EA - Introducing the Effektiv Spenden "Defending Democracy" fund by Sebastian Schienle
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Positive Thinking Mind
In the Great Khan’s Tent
Visualize Meditations
The Mel Robbins Podcast
The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast