The `Conjunction Fallacy' is a fallacy or error in decision making where people judge that a conjunction of two possible events is more likely than one or both of the conjuncts. Here are some examples. EXAMPLE ONE: Doc went to the store and bought tofu, eggplant, broccoli, and frozen meatless lasagna. Is it more likely that Doc is a man or a man who is a vegetarian? EXAMPLE TWO: Doc has a PhD or Doc has a PhD and reads the Wall Street Journal. EXAMPLE THREE: Aaron drove to a party in South Dakota in a Rolls Royce or Aaron drove to a party in South Dakota in a Rolls Royce as is a millionaire. In each example, the former is the correct answer. CONJUNCTION FALLACY: MR. F. HAD A HEART ATTACK. Excerpt from pages 51-52 of the book The Velocity of Information: Human Thinking During Chaotic Times (2022). In 1983, world-renowned psychologists Amos Tversky and Daniel Kahneman published a ground-breaking study on intuitive human cognitive bias (cite 1). They showed that when subjects are asked the likelihood of several alternatives, including single and joint events, they often make a conjunction fallacy. That is, they rate the conjunction of two events as being more likely, or more plausible, than only one of the constituent events. They presented the following fabricated scenarios to 115 undergraduates at Stanford University and the University of British Columbia: A health survey was conducted in a representative sample of adult males in British Columbia of all ages and occupations. Mr. F. was included in the sample. He was selected by chance from a list of participants. Which of the following statements is more probable? (A) Mr. F. has had one or more heart attacks. (B) Mr. F. has had one or more heart attacks and he is over 55 years old. This seemingly transparent problem elicited a substantial proportion (58% selected option B) of conjunction errors among statistically naive respondents (cite 2). WE ARE PRONE TO BELIEVE VIVID STORIES. This example, and countless like it, reveal that we are all subject to the conjunction fallacy, where we regularly violate the laws of probability due to a vivid story. This error in decision-making happens when people judge that a conjunction of two possible events is more likely than one or both of the conjuncts. Innate human reasoning infers that the addition of more details increases the probability of two events occurring simultaneously. (It is also an explanation for why liars tend to add additional or even excessive detail to a given lie in order to predispose the recipient to accepting the lie as truth.) However, the more detailed outcome is just that, more detailed. It is not more plausible or more likely. In fact, the probability of the two events occurring together (in conjunction) is always less than or equal to the probability of either one occurring alone. In other words, a conjunction cannot be more probable than one of its constituents. CONJUNCTION FALLACY DURING THE PANDEMIC. Which of these statements might you have deemed to be most probable on March 25, 2020? (A) The governor has ordered people to stay home. (B) The governor has ordered people to stay home, and state highways are closed. Previous studies of conjunction statements imply that the majority of people presented with these statements would select B. Fortunately, conjunction bias collapses in on itself when too many conditions are stated. Most people are able to identify the mental trickery of a statement with a dozen conjunctions. It no longer makes sense from a face validity standpoint. CITATIONS: (1) Tversky, Amos and Daniel Kahneman. “Extensional Versus Intuitive Reasoning: The Conjunction Fallacy in Probability Judgment.” Psychological Review, 90 (1983): 293–315. (2) Tversky and Kahneman, Extensional Versus Intuitive Reasoning, 293–315. FOLLOW DR. PERRODIN: Twitter @SafetyPhD and subscribe to The Safety Doc YouTube channel & Apple Podcasts. SAFETY DOC WEBSITE, BLOG & BOOKS: www.safetyphd.com. The Safety Doc Podcast is hosted & produced by David P. Perrodin, PhD. This podcast and blog post represent the opinions of David P. Perrodin and his guests to the show. The content here is for informational purposes only. Please consult with your safety professional regarding the unique needs of yourself or your organization.This is episode 172 of The Safety Doc Podcast published on 03-08-2022. GET DOC’S BOOKS. Purchase the preeminent book of scholarship for an uncertain epoch from your favorite bookstore or online retailer and recommend it as a purchase for your local library! The Velocity of Information: Human Thinking During Chaotic Times (2022) by David P. Perrodin.
Purchase Dr. Perrodin’s Books:
Joe Dolio | Assessing the Situation | Body Cams | Mustering Member Checks | LIVESTREAM 7-6-2020
Philipp Heinrich - Face Validity from Germany | Crowd In Theory | The Psychology of Security | LIVESTREAM 6-29-2020
Ex-Convict Larry Lawton | Situational Awareness in Prison | Livestream 6-23-2020
A Tree Fell on My House And Crushed My Bagel | Seattle TAZ | LIVESTREAM 6-11-2020
America is Burning - FACE VALIDITY with Bacon & Doc: LIVESTREAM 05-31-2020
Homeless in San Francisco | Videographer Juan Cabrera | LIVESTREAM 5-28-2020
Cognitive Offloading: How the Internet is Increasingly Taking Over Human Memory
Pandemic Lingo | Shaking a Contact Tracer | Bacon Maldito Interview
Is Special Ed Dead? | Dystopian Back-To-School Videos | Livestream 05-10-2020
Return of Chuck Mak: Face Validity from Pittsburgh
Schools Won’t Open This Fall - Here’s Why | LIVESTEAM 04-30-2020
The Dunning-Kruger Effect | What it is and how to fight it | LIVESTREAM 4-24-2020
Escaped Prisoners Near My House | Humans' Finite Voltage of 100 Days | Civilian Morale | Pranking Steve | LIVESTREAM 4-16-2020
Coronavirus is our Chernobyl (not our 9/11) | LIVESTREAM 4-11-2020
Sir Bryan Bowden | NYC Pandemic Epicenter Face Validity | Protecting Your Right to Privacy
CORONAVIRUS CRUSHES CAMPUS | Interview with University Student Nick Schulaner
Drastic Austerity Measures for K-12 | How Coronavirus Changes School Safety (Livestream 3-31-20)
How Coronavirus Changed America’s Social Contract (Livestream 3-28-20)
My Quarantined Neighbors & Face Validity Update
Face Validity - What's Going on in My Town Today - March 21, 2020
Create your
podcast in
minutes
It is Free
Positive Thinking Mind
In the Great Khan’s Tent
Visualize Meditations
The Mel Robbins Podcast
The Jordan B. Peterson Podcast