Podbean logo
  • Discover
  • Podcast Features
    • Podcast Hosting

      Start your podcast with all the features you need.

    • Podbean AI Podbean AI

      AI-Enhanced Audio Quality and Content Generation.

    • Blog to Podcast

      Repurpose your blog into an engaging podcast.

    • Video to Podcast

      Convert YouTube playlists to podcasts, videos to audios.

  • Monetization
    • Ads Marketplace

      Join Ads Marketplace to earn through podcast sponsorships.

    • PodAds

      Manage your ads with dynamic ad insertion capability.

    • Apple Podcasts Subscriptions Integration

      Monetize with Apple Podcasts Subscriptions via Podbean.

    • Live Streaming

      Earn rewards and recurring income from Fan Club membership.

  • Podbean App
    • Podcast Studio

      Easy-to-use audio recorder app.

    • Podcast App

      The best podcast player & podcast app.

  • Help and Support
    • Help Center

      Get the answers and support you need.

    • Podbean Academy

      Resources and guides to launch, grow, and monetize podcast.

    • Podbean Blog

      Stay updated with the latest podcasting tips and trends.

    • What’s New

      Check out our newest and recently released features!

    • Podcasting Smarter

      Podcast interviews, best practices, and helpful tips.

  • Popular Topics
    • How to Start a Podcast

      The step-by-step guide to start your own podcast.

    • How to Start a Live Podcast

      Create the best live podcast and engage your audience.

    • How to Monetize a Podcast

      Tips on making the decision to monetize your podcast.

    • How to Promote Your Podcast

      The best ways to get more eyes and ears on your podcast.

    • Podcast Advertising 101

      Everything you need to know about podcast advertising.

    • Mobile Podcast Recording Guide

      The ultimate guide to recording a podcast on your phone.

    • How to Use Group Recording

      Steps to set up and use group recording in the Podbean app.

  • All Arts Business Comedy Education
  • Fiction Government Health & Fitness History Kids & Family
  • Leisure Music News Religion & Spirituality Science
  • Society & Culture Sports Technology True Crime TV & Film
  • Live
  • How to Start a Podcast
  • How to Start a Live Podcast
  • How to Monetize a podcast
  • How to Promote Your Podcast
  • How to Use Group Recording
  • Log in
  • Start your podcast for free
  • Podcasting
    • Podcast Features
      • Podcast Hosting

        Start your podcast with all the features you need.

      • Podbean AI Podbean AI

        AI-Enhanced Audio Quality and Content Generation.

      • Blog to Podcast

        Repurpose your blog into an engaging podcast.

      • Video to Podcast

        Convert YouTube playlists to podcasts, videos to audios.

    • Monetization
      • Ads Marketplace

        Join Ads Marketplace to earn through podcast sponsorships.

      • PodAds

        Manage your ads with dynamic ad insertion capability.

      • Apple Podcasts Subscriptions Integration

        Monetize with Apple Podcasts Subscriptions via Podbean.

      • Live Streaming

        Earn rewards and recurring income from Fan Club membership.

    • Podbean App
      • Podcast Studio

        Easy-to-use audio recorder app.

      • Podcast App

        The best podcast player & podcast app.

  • Advertisers
  • Enterprise
  • Pricing
  • Resources
    • Help and Support
      • Help Center

        Get the answers and support you need.

      • Podbean Academy

        Resources and guides to launch, grow, and monetize podcast.

      • Podbean Blog

        Stay updated with the latest podcasting tips and trends.

      • What’s New

        Check out our newest and recently released features!

      • Podcasting Smarter

        Podcast interviews, best practices, and helpful tips.

    • Popular Topics
      • How to Start a Podcast

        The step-by-step guide to start your own podcast.

      • How to Start a Live Podcast

        Create the best live podcast and engage your audience.

      • How to Monetize a Podcast

        Tips on making the decision to monetize your podcast.

      • How to Promote Your Podcast

        The best ways to get more eyes and ears on your podcast.

      • Podcast Advertising 101

        Everything you need to know about podcast advertising.

      • Mobile Podcast Recording Guide

        The ultimate guide to recording a podcast on your phone.

      • How to Use Group Recording

        Steps to set up and use group recording in the Podbean app.

  • Discover
  • Log in
    Sign up free
The Nonlinear Library

The Nonlinear Library

Education

EA - The social disincentives of warning about unlikely risks by Lucius Caviola

EA - The social disincentives of warning about unlikely risks by Lucius Caviola

2024-06-17
Download Right click and do "save link as"
Welcome to The Nonlinear Library, where we use Text-to-Speech software to convert the best writing from the Rationalist and EA communities into audio. This is: The social disincentives of warning about unlikely risks, published by Lucius Caviola on June 17, 2024 on The Effective Altruism Forum.
If you knew about a potential large-scale risk that, although unlikely, could kill millions, would you warn society about it? You might say yes, but many people are reluctant to warn.
In ten studies, Matt Coleman, Joshua Lewis, Christoph Winter, and I explored a psychological barrier to warning about low-probability, high-magnitude risks.
In short, we found that people are reluctant to warn because they could look bad if the risk doesn't occur. And while unlikely risks probably won't happen, they should still be taken seriously if the stakes are large enough. For example, it's worth wearing a seat belt because, even though a car crash is unlikely, its consequences would be so severe. Unfortunately, reputational incentives are often not aligned with what's most beneficial for society.
People would rather keep quiet and hope nothing happens rather than be seen as overly alarmist.
Below, I summarize some of our studies, discuss the underlying psychology of the phenomenon, and suggest possible strategies to encourage risk warning in society. If you want more information about the studies, you can check out
our research paper (including all data, materials, scripts, and pre-registrations).
Reputational fears of warning about unlikely risks
In Study 1, we asked 397 US online participants to imagine they were biological risk experts and believed there was a 5% chance of a new, extremely dangerous virus emerging within the next three years. They could warn society about the risk and recommend a $10-billion investment to develop a vaccine that would prevent all possible harm. If no vaccine is developed and the virus emerges, it will kill millions of people and lead to billions of dollars of economic damage.
But if the virus doesn't emerge, nobody will be harmed, and the money invested in developing the vaccine will have been wasted. Participants were then asked how likely or unlikely they would be to warn society about the risk, and how concerned they would be that society would blame them for warning about the virus.
We hypothesized that people would be reluctant to warn about an unlikely risk due to fear of blame. If true, they should be more willing to warn anonymously. So, we told half the participants their identity would be public if they warned, and the other half that their identity would remain anonymous. We assured both groups that key decision-makers would take their warnings seriously. As expected, participants were less likely to warn society about the risk publicly than anonymously (M = 4.56 vs.
M = 5.25, on a scale from 1 to 7, p < .001). And they were more concerned about being blamed for warning about the risk publicly than anonymously (M = 4.12 vs. M = 2.90, p < .0001).
Warning disincentives are specific to unlikely risks
If you warn about a low-probability risk, the most likely outcome is that the risk won't materialize, and you'll look naive or overly alarmist. In contrast, if you warn about a high probability risk, the risk probably will materialize, and you'll look smart. Thus, we hypothesized that people would be particularly reluctant to publicly warn about unlikely risks compared to likely ones since for the latter, they know that their prediction will probably turn out to be true.
To test this, in Study 2a, 539 US participants imagined they believed that there was an extremely damaging storm that could emerge within the next three months. They were planning to warn society about the risk and recommend that the government invest in minimizing harm from the storm. To test our hypothesis, we randomly varied the likelihood and severity of the storm. It had either a 1% chance of killing 100 million people or a 99% chance ...
view more

More Episodes

LW - Why I funded PIBBSS by Ryan Kidd
2024-09-15
LW - Proveably Safe Self Driving Cars by Davidmanheim
2024-09-15
LW - Not every accommodation is a Curb Cut Effect: The Handicapped Parking Effect, the Clapper Effect, and more by Michael Cohn
2024-09-15
LW - Did Christopher Hitchens change his mind about waterboarding? by Isaac King
2024-09-15
EA - Bringing the International Space Station down safely: A Billion dollar waste? by NickLaing
2024-09-15
LW - Pay-on-results personal growth: first success by Chipmonk
2024-09-15
LW - OpenAI o1, Llama 4, and AlphaZero of LLMs by Vladimir Nesov
2024-09-14
EA - Civil Litigation for Farmed Animals - Notes From EAGxBerkeley Talk by Noa Weiss
2024-09-14
LW - If-Then Commitments for AI Risk Reduction [by Holden Karnofsky] by habryka
2024-09-14
LW - Evidence against Learned Search in a Chess-Playing Neural Network by p.b.
2024-09-14
AF - Estimating Tail Risk in Neural Networks by Jacob Hilton
2024-09-13
AF - Can startups be impactful in AI safety? by Esben Kran
2024-09-13
LW - The Great Data Integration Schlep by sarahconstantin
2024-09-13
LW - AI, centralization, and the One Ring by owencb
2024-09-13
AF - How difficult is AI Alignment? by Samuel Dylan Martin
2024-09-13
EA - Farming groups and veterinarians submit amicus briefs against cruelty to chickens by Sage Max
2024-09-13
LW - Open Problems in AIXI Agent Foundations by Cole Wyeth
2024-09-13
LW - How to Give in to Threats (without incentivizing them) by Mikhail Samin
2024-09-13
LW - Contra papers claiming superhuman AI forecasting by nikos
2024-09-12
EA - Growth theory for EAs - reading list and summary by Karthik Tadepalli
2024-09-12
  • ←
  • 1
  • 2
  • 3
  • 4
  • 5
  • 6
  • 7
  • 8
  • 9
  • 10
  • →
012345678910111213141516171819

Get this podcast on your
phone, FREE

Download Podbean app on App Store Download Podbean app on Google Play

Create your
podcast in
minutes

  • Full-featured podcast site
  • Unlimited storage and bandwidth
  • Comprehensive podcast stats
  • Distribute to Apple Podcasts, Spotify, and more
  • Make money with your podcast
Get started

It is Free

  • Podcast Services

    • Podcast Features
    • Pricing
    • Enterprise Solution
    • Private Podcast
    • The Podcast App
    • Live Stream
    • Audio Recorder
    • Remote Recording
    • Podbean AI
  •  
    • Create a Podcast
    • Video Podcast
    • Start Podcasting
    • Start Radio Talk Show
    • Education Podcast
    • Church Podcast
    • Nonprofit Podcast
    • Get Sermons Online
    • Free Audiobooks
  • MONETIZATION & MORE

    • Podcast Advertising
    • Dynamic Ads Insertion
    • Apple Podcasts Subscriptions
    • Switch to Podbean
    • YouTube to Podcast
    • Blog to Podcast
    • Submit Your Podcast
    • Podbean Plugins
    • Developers
  • KNOWLEDGE BASE

    • How to Start a Podcast
    • How to Start a Live Podcast
    • How to Monetize a Podcast
    • How to Promote Your Podcast
    • Mobile Podcast Recording Guide
    • How to Use Group Recording
    • Podcast Advertising 101
  • Support

    • Support Center
    • What’s New
    • Free Webinars
    • Podcast Events
    • Podbean Academy
    • Podbean Amplified Podcast
    • Badges
    • Resources
  • Podbean

    • About Us
    • Podbean Blog
    • Careers
    • Press and Media
    • Green Initiative
    • Affiliate Program
    • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Cookie Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Consent Preferences
  • Copyright © 2015-2025 Podbean.com