Big Gay Nerds: Episode 137 (Monster of the Week 1.2)

Alright gang, it's time to solve a mystery! A teenager has gone missing in upstate New York, and their neighbor says that a strange flying light is to blame. Is this the work of extraterrestrials, or something even stranger? In order to properly hunt this monster (or monsters), our heroes will have to intimidate a newspaper reporter, bluff their way past a stern mother, roll dice (in and out of character), and chat up some drunks. Standard monster-hunting protocol.